Top Five: Rangers Most Deserving Of All-Star Spots

Josh Hamilton leads the way on the list of Rangers most deserving of All-Star consideration.

With the Rangers suddenly having one of the best seasons in franchise history, led by a number of stars carrying subpar performers in several spots, the team is poised to yet again have solid representation in an All-Star Game. Here are the most deserving of those stars:

No. 5 - Michael Young

Young is a tale of two sides of the ball. Offensively, his recent renaissance puts him into contention. Defensively, he has been poor again this season, though his closest competitors -- Alex Rodriguez and Jose Bautista -- are nothing special themselves. In some circles, listing Young here would be viewed as a mistake. In others -- some within baseball -- he is viewed as possibly the most important guy on the team. 

If the AL takes two third basemen, Longoria and Beltre make it, and that's that. If the league takes a third, he has a shot. He is outhitting A-Rod, but if Bautista gets consideration as a third baseman (he has played in 41 games as an outfielder and 30 as a third baseman), Young is a tougher sell, particularly since a good Blue Jays team will be viewed as deserving multiple members of the team and the Rangers will have two-three other position players.

PA Slash wOBA +/- WAR
Evan Longoria 301 .304/.382/.540 .387 +4 3.2
Adrian Beltre 283 .336/.371/.528 .390 +6 3.0
Jose Bautista 288 .222/.350/.526 .378 -3 1.6
Alex Rodriguez 275 .277/.349/.459 .350 0 1.8
Michael Young 316 .309/.358/.476 .360 -5 1.6


No. 4 - Elvis Andrus

Elvis needs July 1 to arrive quickly. Two weeks ago he was the team's biggest slam dunk choice, but a recent slump drops him back to the pack, both in real numbers and perception. His combination of on-base ability and stellar defense still makes him a fine candidate, though he would greatly improve his chances by bouncing back this week offensively.

This is another position where the Ranger's chances will depend largely on how many players are carried. Jeter will start, so if only two shortstops are taken, Andrus has to beat out the rest of the field. Going by these numbers Gonzalez has a good case to be on the team.

PA Slash wOBA +/- WAR
Derek Jeter 318 .283/.336/.423 .337 +3 1.7
Marco Scutaro 321 .283/.353/.389 .330 +9 1.8
Elvis Andrus 301 .275/.360/.322 .316 +9 1.2
Alex Gonzalez 275 .269/.305/.496 .347 +10 1.6
Reid Brignac 176 .281/.347/.394 .328 +2 1.0


No. 3 - Colby Lewis

Arguably the best pickup in baseball in the offseason and a terrific comeback player of the year candidate, Lewis has been hugely important to the Rangers. If the AL faces difficult roster decisions, he could be an odd man out, but for the wrong reasons.

Lewis has seven wins and a 3.07 ERA, but his home run issues and some early season high walk totals are what currently keep him from being among the most dominant starters in the AL.He is third in the AL in WHIP and first in BA against, two numbers that don't tell us much analytically but are popular within baseball, so that could bode well for him. It is hard to distinguish candidates after the first four guys, so Lewis' chances may revolve around roster shuffling.

Cliff Lee 77.2 67 2.55 3.10 3.4
Francisco Liriano 87.2 93 2.98 3.07 3.4
Jered Weaver 94.2 107 3.04 3.28 2.7
Ricky Romero 96.1 96 3.08 3.26 2.5
Phil Hughes 82.1 78 3.17 3.85 2.1
Felix Hernandez 103.2 97 3.39 3.52 2.2
Justin Verlander 94.0 85 3.54 3.96 2.3
Colby Lewis 93.2 90 3.07 3.97 1.9
David Price 91.2 73 2.45 4.23 1.6
Zack Greinke 96.0 83 3.94 3.82 1.8
Clay Buchholz 91.0 62 2.47 4.28 2.2
Jon Lester 92.0 96 3.13 3.57 2.5


No. 2 - Vladimir Guerrero

I would argue that Colby Lewis is a more important player for the Rangers, but when competition is taken into account, Guerrero is an easier candidate. Whether Vlad should be judged against other DHs or all of the best hitters in the league is basically a moot point because Guerrero is on the ballot as a DH, is deserving as the starter among the choices, and is in fact lapping the field in voting (1.7 million to Hideki Matsui's 825k as of June 14).

PA Slash wOBA +/- WAR
Vladimir Guerrero 273 .327/.366/.554 .390 +1 1.9
David Ortiz 238 .260/.366/.555 .387 0 1.4
Johnny Damon 280 .274/.369/.402 .348 0 1.1
Luke Scott 219 .307/.367/.492 .372 0 1.1


No. 1 - Josh Hamilton

Hamilton was rocking along having a very unspectacular season until June, when he and hitting coach Clint Hurdle seemed to find the answer to his timing issues. He's 37-78 this month with seven home runs, and he will make his second All-Star Game as a Ranger. We can only hope that he won't be talked into participating in another home run contest.

Reviewing the below numbers, Hamilton's WAR is damaged by a harsh -1.6 UZR from his limited play in center field, but he clearly belongs as one of the starting AL outfielders in Anaheim.

PA Slash wOBA +/- WAR
Josh Hamilton 292 .337/.381/.600 .422 0 3.1
Alex Rios 265 .317/.377/.558 .409 +8 3.4
Carl Crawford 298 .307/.367/.492 .381 +9 3.7
Torii Hunter 283 .293/.367/.528 .378 -3 2.1
Magglio Ordonez 260 .333/.408/.522 .407 0 2.7
Ichiro 309 .337/.389/.440 .366 +11 2.6
David DeJesus 297 .328/.400/.492 .389 -6 2.3
Nelson Cruz 126 .327/.405/.729 .469 +3 2.3


Honorable Mention: 

Darren Oliver - Oliver's raw numbers are slightly better than Neftali Feliz's, but neither stands out in a group of excellent AL relievers that includes Mariano Rivera, Rafael Soriano, Jose Valverde, JJ Putz, Darren O'Day, Brian Duensing and Daniel Bard. What does stand out is that the Rangers possess three of those dominant relievers.

Neftali Feliz - Feliz may make the team, since he leads the league with 19 saves (and three holds) and has blown just two. Rivera and Soriano, for two, have been a little better, but Feliz does have a good chance of getting one of the spots, particularly if the AL takes four relievers. But Feliz is not among the 3-4 best relievers in the league and therefore really shouldn't make the roster.

Nelson Cruz - If only he had stayed healthy. As the above chart shows, Cruz has been absolutely dominant when on the field, but a little over 100 at bats is a tough sell.

Ian Kinsler - Kinsler is almost as deserving as Young when position is taken into account, but he is clearly not one of the three best second basemen in the league -- Robinson Cano, Dustin Pedroia and Orlando Hudson are. Cano and Pedroia are easy choices unless the AL opts to classify Ben Zobrist at second, as he listed on the ballot.

Stats: wOBA+/-WARxFIP

Trending Discussions

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join SB Nation Dallas

You must be a member of SB Nation Dallas to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at SB Nation Dallas. You should read them.

Join SB Nation Dallas

You must be a member of SB Nation Dallas to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at SB Nation Dallas. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.